✓
What we found
Track 1 closed honest: two checklist items passed (one via surrogate), two failed. Claim not proved — finishing a patch is not a prove.
Prop-01 E1b honesty close-out: §5.3 Pass · §5.4 Pass (surrogate) · §5.1 Fail · §5.2 Fail/KILLED. support_claim false.
→ Live findings
∿
What just closed
Finished: inconclusive. Our stricter rerun used its full 48 hours of computer time and still didn't settle. Its agreement score ended at 0.0515, just above the 0.05 bar we set in advance. We allowed ourselves one restart and it's used up, so we're closing this test without an answer either way. It doesn't show early dark energy works, and it doesn't rule it out. Results stay hidden, because the runs never agreed. Puzzle not solved. Proved yet: no.
Closed INCONCLUSIVE 2026-10-21. G1b (ΛCDM baseline restart) hit the 48 h compute-active cap: diag_ok FAIL, final cobaya R−1 0.0515 (bar < 0.05). Per ED note 2026-10-19 (one restart only) G1b FAIL → G1 INCONCLUSIVE (baseline not converged); no EDE arm scored. Stays blinded (no H0 mean/sd, T or χ² unblinded). Not improved / null / falsified. support_claim false · proved_yet false. Receipt: sims/prop03/results/reopen/receipt_g1b_verdict.{md,json}.
→ Track 3 · closed, inconclusive
◈
What we won’t claim
Track 2 finished: smart picking helped a little (about +0.027), but not by the 0.05 bar we set in advance. No win claimed — an honest negative.
Prop-02 GNN primary scored 2026-10-13: 4.1 Fail · 4.3 Fail · 4.4 Pass (directional). prop02_success_claimed false — honest negative.
→ Honesty first